Detroit Schools Just Aren't That Crowded
Claims of ‘militant’ teacher can’t overcome actual figures reported by district
The Detroit Free Press reported that teachers in Detroit’s public schools plan to oppose a new school calendar that adds five workdays without increasing their pay.
The story quoted a “militant” teachers union member making a claim about Detroit classroom sizes.
“The district already has terrible trouble filling its numerous vacancies, because of the low pay and difficult nature of our work,” said teacher Ben Royal. Royal is a member of Equal Opportunity Now/By Any Means Necessary, a division of the Detroit Federation of Teachers that takes a more militant stance, according to the Detroit Free Press. “This causes terrible overcrowding in many, many classrooms, which means students don’t get the attention they deserve, and student achievement declines.”
Teacher claims about overcrowded classes are not challenged by the media. Because of that, Michigan Capitol Confidential has submitted Freedom Of Information Act requests to school districts, seeking class size data. According to information provided by the Detroit Public Schools Community District, Royal’s claims of overcrowding are greatly exaggerated.
Just 4% of the classes in Detroit’s public school district held 40 or more students, according to data released this fall. That comes to 340 classes out of 8,701 classes during the 2018-19 school year. The average Detroit classroom size was 26.73 students. The basis for that average excludes 1,502 classes that have fewer than 10 students.
The largest class in the Detroit system was a team sports class, which had 107 students. The second-largest class, at 88 students, was also a team sports class. There was also a team sports class with 81 students that was the third-largest class.
Most of the Detroit classes with 40 or more students were physical education or team sports classes. The largest academic class was a humanities class at Western International High School, which had 59 students.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Hike Taxes — Or Just Wait A Half Year
Budget growth can mean more money for roads without tax hikes
The governor wants a $2.5 billion tax hike in order to spend $1.9 billion on the roads and another $600 million on other priorities, and she proposed to implement this over two years. Legislators have their own opinions and some of them may want to find budget cuts in order to spend more on the roads. This tax-or-cut dichotomy misses an important point: The budget has grown a lot, and growth matters more than either tax hikes or budget cuts.
Lawmakers can accomplish their policy goals with the $33.9 billion in revenues already collected by state taxes.
State revenues have grown over time. State revenue is up $8.7 billion since 2010, which is a 15 percent gain above inflation. Those type of gains — along with the 2015 transportation tax hikes — have let the state spend $1.7 billion more on the roads over the period, which is a 57 percent increase above inflation.
The proposed tax hike is the equivalent of 2.6 years of revenue growth under current tax collection trends. To put it another way, the state would raise more money from three years of growth than it would raise under the governor’s two-year tax hike. It’s not an issue, then, of what the state needs to cut so it can afford to fix the roads, it’s an issue of deciding what to do with the extra money that is already coming in.
An ever-increasing flow of state tax revenue makes pursuing budget priorities, like spending more on the roads, easier to do. And if road maintenance is a priority, lawmakers ought to put it higher than other state spending when they agree on their annual budget.
A tax hike is different. It is a way for lawmakers to avoid those prioritization decisions. It instead kicks the question of where the money for roads will come from over to households, who will have to instead reprioritize their own budgets in order to afford the tax hike.
Lawmakers spend on items that ought to be less important than the roads. Budget growth, however, means that they can continue to waste money and spend more on roads even without a tax hike.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Want to support our work?
Keep free-market news flowing with your gift to Michigan Capitol Confidential today
Make a gift! Already a supporter
More From CapCon