Analysis

Ten other numbers to know about the Michigan budget

Gov. Whitmer’s ‘10 most important budget numbers’ left out a few items

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer offered her take on “the 10 most important numbers in the state budget” Tuesday in an op-ed for The Detroit News

As the Mackinac Center’s director of fiscal policy, I thought it would be good to make a list of my own. These are 10 other numbers to know about the 2023 Michigan budget.

  1. $7 billion: The most notable part of the state budget is what isn’t in it. Lawmakers tend to spend every dollar they have available, but this year they didn’t spend $7 billion. This money can be used to help lower taxes, or to pay for whatever priorities lawmakers have later.
  2. $17.4 billion: The budget has grown a lot since the pandemic began. Both federal transfers and revenue from the state’s taxes and fees contributed to these gains. It’s unclear whether the increases in spending have come with similar improvements in service.
  3. 10.2%: Adjusting for recent and expected inflation, the budget is still 10.2% above prepandemic levels.
  4. $6.3 billion: The total spending for next year is down $6.3 billion from current-year levels, as temporary federal pandemic spending gets phased out. Total money that was transferred from Washington to Lansing declined from $40.4 billion to $31.1 billion.
  5. 4 years: It took four years for the governor to give up her insistence that the state road conditions required the state to raise taxes. This budget finally increases state spending on roads without a tax hike, using the state’s growing resources.
  6. 3.3%: Even with increases in federal spending and state spending, the road-funding governor has not made much of an improvement in road funding. The state transportation budget is only up 3.3% when adjusting for inflation and expected inflation in the upcoming year.
  7. $2.275 billion: Amount of pension debt payments in the budget. Lawmakers have not set aside enough money to pay for the pension benefits earned by government workers. Paying down this debt protects pensioners and saves taxpayers money in interest.
  8. 149: Number of special district projects in the budget, whereby lawmakers place a specific spending item at their request. All told, the projects cost taxpayers over $1 billion this year. While there is a perennial desire for lawmakers all around the country to bring home the bacon, the way they direct taxpayer money to legislators’ projects these days is a recent practice that didn’t happen in budgets before fiscal year 2015-16.
  9. 519: How many pages it took to lay out the state’s $75.8 billion budget.
  10. 76: How many days the budget was approved before the start of the next fiscal year in October.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

Flint school district requires masks for fall classes, then changes course

Masks are now merely recommended, not required, in the district that gave every employee a $22K COVID bonus

A new reporting tool created by the state of Michigan showed that fewer than five children in the Genesee Intermediate School District tested positive for COVID-19 during the week ending July 13. Even so, Kevelin Jones, superintendent of Flint Community Schools, announced that students in his district would be required to wear face masks, before immediately reversing the decision. The district, one of 21 in the Genesee ISD, currently recommends mask-wearing instead.

Jones wrote a letter to district parents on July 21. As reported by WXYZ-TV, it said: “Schools across the country have experienced spikes in COVID-19 cases after extended breaks, and Flint Community Schools is no different. Based on our experiences last school year, we are taking this extra measure to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 and help protect our school community.” The letter can no longer be found on the district’s website.

The Michigan Intermediate School District COVID-19 Case Reporting database shows the number of positive COVID-19 cases in the state’s ISDs. For the Genesee ISD, the seven-day average was less than five per week, as of July 13. It is unclear why Flint Community Schools briefly announced the mask requirement before rescinding it. Superintendent Jones did not respond to an email seeking comment.

Flint Community Schools is no stranger to controversy when it comes to COVID-19 policies. It received $50,000 per student in COVID relief funds, by far the most money any Michigan school district received, on a per-pupil basis. Yet the district was inconsistent in offering in-person instruction after closing its doors for the pandemic in March 2020.

The Flint superintendent sent a letter to families in February 2021 to tell them that sneeze guards had not yet been installed, which was one factor deterring in-class instruction.

School officials had said they would install air conditioning before the 2021-22 school year. The installation did not happen in time, resulting in additional school cancellations. District leaders also chose to close schools due to COVID-19 case rates and after the Oxford High School shooting, out of an “abundance of caution.” These are all days children spent out of the classroom.

The Flint school district has shed more than 20,000 students this century, going from 23,962 enrolled students in August 2000 to 3,623 in August 2021.

Even though the district continues to lose students, it gave each employee a $22,000 bonus, using federal COVID-19 funds.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.