Commentary

Why School Choice is So Valuable

Detroit Schools doesn’t expect academic progress for a decade

The head of the public school district in Detroit doesn’t expect academic progress for up to 10 years. It’s a good thing students in the city have other options.

The district had to be bailed out by state taxpayers and recently its chief executive testified before legislators. The Detroit News noted the remarks from Alycia Meriweather, interim superintendent for the Detroit Public Schools Community District:

Meriweather said the Legislature’s debt relief for the school system has helped educators turn their attention back to improving academic achievement. But she warned it could be years before lawmakers see progress in test scores and academic growth.

“It will take us eight to 10 years to get there,” she said. “We have a lot of work to do.”

As a colleague noted: “If I'm a parent with a second-grader in DPS, I'm really glad there's plenty of school choice options available so I don't have to accept that decade of failure for my child.”

The traditional public school system in the city has performed the worst in the nation on every one of the “nation’s report card” tests (National Assessment of Education Progress) for about a decade. At one point, the executive director of the council that administered the assessment said this about Detroit Public Schools: “There is no jurisdiction of any kind, at any level, at any time in the 30-year history of NAEP that has ever registered such low numbers. They are barely above what one would expect simply by chance, as if the kids simply guessed at the answers.”

For this reason and others, about half the students in Detroit have fled the traditional public school system, mostly to charters or nearby districts.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

MSU Bans Smoking on Campus But Reports No Violations

Is the law about enforcement or education?

No records have been collected that might indicate whether a new smoking ban on the Michigan State University campus has had any effect in its first three months.

The measure raised eyebrows last summer because it also reaches into private vehicles traveling on public roads that pass through the sprawling campus. Drivers and passengers, or anyone else on MSU property, are subject to a $150 fine for violations.

MSU responded to a Freedom of Information Act request by saying that no documents exist that are related to enforcement of the policy, which went into effect on Aug. 15. The request for documents asked the university for the number of tickets and warnings issued up until Nov. 18.

“Enforcement was never going to be a focus of this effort,” said MSU spokesman Jason Cody in an email. “Hence, we have not given out any tickets. And our police do not track warnings.”

The ban includes the use of e-cigarettes and smokeless tobacco on campus.

“It’s a bad idea to keep laws on the books without enforcing them,” said criminal justice analyst Kahryn Riley of the Mackinac Center for Public Policy in an email. “Maintaining a free society depends so much on holding everyone accountable to the laws. Every time we pass one knowing that we’re not actually responsible for obeying it, we’re reinforcing the notion that the law is arbitrary, or is just a tool for political posturing.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.