News Story

Budget Watchdog: State Has Billions in Unbudgeted Retiree Costs

Former Gov. Jennifer Granholm told the MIRS news agency she was handing over a balanced state budget that even had a surplus.

But one watchdog accounting agency is saying Granholm is ignoring $50.1 billion the state owes to its workers, mostly for retiree pensions and health care.

Sheila Weinberg, CEO of The Institute for Truth in Accounting, said their analysis of Michigan's 2009 audited financial statement found the state in a "precarious financial position."

Truth in Accounting, an Illinois-based nonprofit organization that fact-checks government financial information, found that each taxpayer in Michigan would have to pay $16,400 to cover that $50.1 billion deficit.

"Instead of having to write the check now, they go ahead and promise the benefits, and those don't have to be paid until they are long out of office," Weinberg said. "Truthful accounting would include the health care and pension benefits that the employees are earning each year. … That cost is there, and it is real, and it should be included in the budget."

Included in that $50.1 billion deficit is an $8 billion pension shortfall and a $32 billion shortfall for retiree health care, Weinberg said.

James Hohman, fiscal policy analyst with the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, said the sheer size of the pension and retiree health care liability indicates the state has been "very generous."

"Michigan can reform these liabilities before having to make payments on them," Hohman said.

The Institute for Truth in Accounting has reviewed other states' budgets. Weinberg said the state with the highest burden on taxpayers was New Jersey at $47,000 per taxpayer, just short of three times as much as Michigan.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Michigan Fiscal Policy a Two-Sided Coin

Michigan is faced with a financial crisis due to a projected budget overspending crisis approaching $2 billion for this fiscal year. It is understandable that a newly elected governor and Legislature are preoccupied with stopping the fiscal bleeding. Republican leaders are arguing that the state budget can be balanced with spending cuts. Democratic leaders are arguing that spending cuts alone are too drastic and will result in an unacceptable reduction in state services and that cuts must be accompanied by revenue increases – political speak for tax increases. 

State leaders need to be mindful that balancing the state budget is only one side of a two-sided coin in regards to state fiscal policy. Enacting state policies that foster economic growth is equally important if the state is going break the cycle of annual fiscal crises. If Michigan is to regain economic vitality it will require both spending reductions as well as job growth.

Future job growth in the state requires the fundamental restructuring of the current oppressive regulatory system that serves as an effective barrier to job creation. Government does not create jobs, but bad government policies can certainly destroy the opportunity for private-sector job creation.  A good place to start is for our elected leaders to quickly take the following action:

Michigan residents have a reasonable expectation that elected officials can do more than one thing at time. It is time for our leaders to meet those expectations.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.