News Bite

‘Science Settled’ On Indoor Dining?

When Robert Gordon, the director of the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, ordered the state’s bars and restaurants to prohibit inside dining through Dec. 20, he said there is no debate on the issue.

“The science on eating and drinking inside is settled,” Gordon said, according to WDIV.

But many other states have not prohibited inside dining, which suggests the science may not be settled. A Nov. 20 report from the Kaiser Family Foundation said: “Seven states have recently closed restaurants to indoor or all in-person dining while 20 allow indoor dining but impose capacity limits. States have been more willing to close bars — 16 states have closed bars to indoor service. However, 15 states continue to have no restrictions on restaurants and 13 do not restrict service at bars.”

AARP did a nationwide survey of states, updated Dec. 9. It found that states have chosen a wide variety of ways to deal with restaurants, bars and the coronavirus.

In Maine, Democratic Gov. Janet Mills has allowed restaurants to remain open to in-service dining, though they must close at 9 p.m. and seat no more than 50 people. Bars and tasting rooms, however, can not offer indoor service. In New Jersey, Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy has ordered bars and restaurants to stop offering indoor service from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. In Pennsylvania, Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf has allowed indoor seating for bars and restaurants as long as alcohol can only be served for on-premises consumption and must accompany a meal.

Gordon was appointed to his position on Jan. 14, 2019, by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.

His biography on the state website reads: “Director Gordon has a distinguished career in public service. Most recently, he served as senior vice president of finance and global strategy for the non-profit College Board.”

"Prior to joining the College Board, Director Gordon served in the U.S. Department of Education as acting assistant secretary at the Office of Planning, Evaluation and Policy Development. He spent four years at the U.S. Office of Management and Budget, including service as acting deputy director.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Bite

State Health Department Head Blames Residents For High COVID Numbers

But nearby states show similar pattern even without strict lockdowns

Robert Gordon, director of the Michigan Department of Heath and Human Services, has blamed state residents for the continuing spread of COVID-19. This week, Gordon extended a lockdown of inside service at bars and restaurants to Dec. 20

“Because COVID is everywhere in our state and because sadly ... we still have a lot of folks who are, um ... we’re not doing all the things we need to do ... If we are all doing those things, we will get the virus under control,” Gordon said on the radio program Michigan's Big Show. “But we’re doing these things partly, not all the way, so the virus continues to spread.”

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, Gordon, and other state officials have repeatedly blamed state residents not following state orders for persistently high levels of confirmed new cases. But they have not offered evidenced to back up their claims that the state's people are responsible.

Meanwhile, the coronavirus cases in Michigan is similar to the pattern seen in other states, such as Ohio, Indiana and Pennsylvania. That's according to Worldometers.info.

Indiana, Ohio and Pennsylvania still allow bars and restaurants to have inside dining while Michigan does not.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

Family Says Clumsy COVID Orders, Isolation, Caused Dad’s Decline And Death

William Hall Jr. of Southeast Michigan died in a nursing home in August, in a death attributed to sepsis. But his family says the real reason William Hall Jr. died when he did was that a horror show of neglect made possible by state government anti-COVID restrictions allowed his condition to be hidden from those who loved him.

William Hall III of Romulus said his 82-year-old father went into rapid decline during the spring and summer, at a time when visitors were barred from the nursing home. The only outside contact he was allowed was by telephone or through the window of his room.

As his father’s ability to communicate by phone dissipated, Hall III said, he was left alone, suffering from tennis ball-sized bedsore wounds that his family was unaware of.

“The last time I got to hug him was in February,” Hall III said. “Until I got to hug him when he was in the hospital unconscious. I should have been able to hug him every week.”

He blames both the nursing home, Medilodge of Milford, and Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer for imposing what he called nonsensical restrictions that harmed the very people they were purported to protect.

“Whitmer thinks she can do anything she wants without any kind of accountability,” he said.

Michigan’s nursing home policies during the coronavirus pandemic have been controversial almost from the beginning. Whitmer’s administration has been accused of ordering nursing home patients with COVID-19 returned to facilities ill-prepared to deal with the outbreak.

But William Hall Jr.’s death illustrates another potential shortcoming of broad-based anti-pandemic government orders. Hall didn’t contract COVID-19; he suffered from dementia and assorted other ailments.

His wife, also frail and elderly, is in assisted living and was unable to visit, Hall III said, so the primary task of supporting and visiting his father fell to him.

But after Whitmer’s initial emergency lockdown orders in March, he was denied all access to his father for almost three weeks, he said. After that, he could see his father, but only through the nursing home window.

Nationally, many health care experts have warned about the perils of isolation, loneliness and despair among nursing home residents who have been cut off from the outside world by COVID restrictions. Michigan officials have acknowledged those concerns.

But at the same time — citing the vulnerability that the infirm elderly in confined living facilities have to the virus — the state has enacted some of the nation’s strictest guidelines on nursing home patient contact.

Those guidelines were eased in October, allowing for scheduled visits for those willing to undergo COVID screening, with close contact limited to 15 minutes. But with November bringing a surge in new cases, the restrictions have been reimposed in most instances.

Hall III said it was Michigan and Medilodge restrictions that precluded his family from discovering his father’s deteriorating condition.

Medilodge media director Bill Gray declined to comment when reached by Michigan Capitol Confidential.

“We are not participating in any media inquiries at this time,” he said. “We are concentrating on taking care of our residents and our employees during the pandemic.”

Whitmer’s office did not respond to a request for comment.

Hall III said he filed a complaint with state nursing home regulators and was told last week that Medilodge Milford will be cited for violating health care standards. A spokesman for the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs said the facility is under investigation but declined further comment.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.