News Story

Michigan Democrats will lose House majority but hold speakership

As 54-54 House tie looms, Democrat Joe Tate keeps gavel

Correction: An earlier version of this story cited an incorrect roll call vote.

The Nov. 7 election cost Michigan Democrats their House majority. Reps. Kevin Coleman, D-Westland, and Lori Stone, D-Warren, won their mayoral races and will resign their seats in the House.

This will drop the Democrats from a 56-54 majority to a 54-54 tie. The total number of House members will drop from 110 to 108. By Michigan law, House votes require a majority of lawmakers, not just a majority of those present. A 108-member House requires 55 votes to pass a bill. Without at least one House Republican voting with Democrats, a bill will not pass.

In times past, a deadlocked House has led to a shared speakership.

But thanks to House Rule 77, House Speaker Joe Tate, D-Detroit, will hold the gavel alone when the House splits 54-54.

Rule 77 was the final House rule of the 102nd Legislature. Pictured below, Rule 77 sets the terms for an equally divided House.

Only in the event of a 55-55 tie is a new vote held for the Speaker. In a 54-54 tie it defaults to the current speaker, Tate.

Rule 77 was passed Jan. 11, in House Resolution 1 of 2023. The resolution passed in a voice vote, where no tally was taken.

The soon-to-be vacated House seats will now be subject to special runoff elections, which will likely take months.

This will not be the first time the Michigan House has been evenly divided. Thirty years ago there was a shared speakership in Michigan.

On Jan. 13, 1993, Reps. Curtis Hertel Sr., D-Detroit, and Paul Hillegonds, R-Holland, were unanimously elected co-speakers of the Michigan House.

As of Wednesday, Coleman and Stone still hold their seats and Democrats still hold a majority. Coleman is expected to take his new office Nov. 17, The Detroit News reports. Stone will assume her new office within weeks.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

MichiganVotes Bills

Scripps: One-half percent of Michigan’s land needed for wind, solar projects

Land devoted to wind and solar would go from 17,000 acres to 209,000 under state zoning plan

A two-bill package that will give the Michigan Public Service Commission the final say in siting large solar and wind projects in Michigan has advanced to the full Senate.

If the bills are enacted into law, about 0.5% of Michigan’s acreage could be permitted for wind and solar projects.

The Senate Energy and Environment Committee on Tuesday approved amended versions of House bills 5120 and 5121. The House passed the bills last week.

As Michigan implements Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s MI Healthy Climate plan, planners have run into one consistent problem: local communities that reject large-scale solar fields and wind turbines. Under the bills, as amended by the committee, local communities could only reject these projects in the event of incomplete paperwork, lawmakers said.

If a local government rejects a project for any other reason, the developer could present it to the Michigan Public Service Commission for approval. Local communities would have no veto. That would reside with the commission, whose three members are appointed by the governor.

Dan Scripps, chairman of the commission, testified at Tuesday’s meeting. He said it was necessary to vest the commission with these powers to meet Michigan’s clean energy goals.

About 17,000 acres in Michigan were now covered by wind and solar infrastructure, Scripps said. On the high end, that number could balloon to about 209,000 acres, he said.

“The highest number in terms of the amount of acreage of direct land use under a high-growth scenario, again, is about 209,393 acres of new land,” Scripps testified. “That's a big number. But in context, it represents about 0.55% of Michigan's total projected or total area. And so it’s a significant growth — and I am not here to pretend otherwise — over what’s in place today. But it's still about one-half of 1% of Michigan's total land.”

The committee approved the bill by an 8-5 vote along party lines. One lawmaker, Sen. Rosemary Bayer, D-West Bloomfield, passed.

To be enacted into law, both bills would need to be passed in identical forms by the House and Senate and be signed by Whitmer.

 

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.