Tim Rugg, a 22-year veteran of the Ann Arbor Fire Department, was fired in Dec. 2021 for refusing to comply with a COVID vaccination mandate. But before that happened, he was disciplined for attending a protest against Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s lockdown policies during the COVID pandemic, Michigan Capitol Confidential has learned through an open records request.

An employee disciplinary report filed against Rugg says he was given a verbal reprimand for attending an April 30, 2020, protest at the Michigan Capitol.

It cites his own statement — “Rugg admitted to traveling to the State Capitol on April 30, 2020 to attend an event with several hundred people” — as well as media photos showing people who were unmasked and also not practicing social distancing.

Ruggs was suspended and then fired in late 2021 for not getting a COVID-19 vaccine. Ruggs made an unsuccessful attempt to get an exemption from the mandate, citing religious grounds.

A month after the lockdown protest and week after the murder of George Floyd by Minneapolis police, Ann Arbor Mayor Christopher Taylor attended a Black Lives Matter protest. By attending the June 2, 2020, event, Taylor defied the governor’s lockdown orders. Two days later, Whitmer violated her own order by attending a similar event.

Rugg is suing the city over his termination, as CapCon has previously reported. CapCon submitted a FOIA request for his personnel file after he was terminated from city employment solely for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine. Rugg was one of only a few city employees who was not granted a religious exemption.

The city notes in Rugg’s personnel file:

Media photos from the [April 2020 lockdown protest] event show that social distancing and face coverings were not being used. Other alternative and reasonable means of communication and interaction with state elected officials to express his constitutional rights could have been utilized. His attendance and exposure placed himself, members of the Ann Arbor Fire Department and citizens of the City at extremely high risk for COVID-19 exposure. By his actions, D/O Rugg violated Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s Executive Order No. 2020-59.

Taylor and a spokeswoman for the city of Ann Arbor did not respond to emails seeking comment.

Two bills introduced in the Michigan House of Representatives would bring transparency to the state budget process. House bills 4750 and 4751 were introduced this month by Reps. Tom Kuhn, R-Troy, and Donni Steele, R-Orion.

The bills are tie-barred together. Both bills must pass for either to be enacted into law. H.B. 4750 would require sponsoring legislators to provide written statements regarding legislatively directed spending items. H.B. 4751 specifies what information would have to be included in these statements. It would also require that the statement be public for 48 hours prior to voting. 

“It’s shocking we can sit on a subcommittee and the night before we get a $2 billion to $3 billion budget request with no details and no info, and we cannot find out what these things are about. ” Kuhn told Michigan Capitol Confidential. “It is ridiculous.”

Kuhn voiced frustratation with the secrecy often involved in appropriations, noting that sometimes he’s not given a copy of the bill until right before it comes up for a vote. 

Michigan Capitol Confidential reported in December that the 2023 state budget was filled with secrecy:

Dozens of organizations were awarded tens of millions in taxpayer dollars, with legislators offering no clear parameters for granting the money. And when CapCon asked members of the Senate Appropriations Committee about the process of determining who got grants and for how much, they did not respond.

If Kuhn and Steele’s legislation were to become law, legislation that appropriates taxpayer funds would have to include:

• The sponsoring legislator’s name
• The name and location of the intended recipient or the intended location of the project or activity
• The purpose of the spending and why it is a suitable use for taxpayer funds
• A certification that immediate family of the sponsor does not have a financial interest in the spending item

No chamber of the Legislature, one of its committees or a subcommittee could approve an appropriation unless the information mentioned above had been publicly available on the internet for at least 48 hours.

One grant that would have been affected by these bills was an allocation of $500,000, which lawmakers gave to the National Association of Yemeni Americans  in the 2023 state budget.

The association’s website is no longer available, and nobody from the group has posted on Facebook since 2021. An email sent to the organization came back as undeliverable.

Members of Michigan’s House and Senate appropriations committees did not respond to requests for comment.