Like CapCon on Facebook
Follow CapCon on XState’s Data Show Masks In Schools Don’t Work, Tells Kids To Wear Them Anyway
Age 5-18 COVID transmission rates almost the same regardless of school mask rules
Masks do not appear to prevent the transmission of COVID-19 among school-aged children, according to new data released by the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. The state health department says students should still wear a mask regardless.
Transmission rates among school-age children are, in the words of the report, “washed out” or “have become more similar.” That is, transmission rates were nearly the same, regardless of whether schools in a given community imposed mask mandates. The most recent data even shows that communities where schools had few or no mask rules experienced lower transmission rates among school-age children.
The state nevertheless concludes, “It remains important to mask up in indoor settings (schools and otherwise) to prevent transmission.”
The similar school transmission rate pattern appeared in November, according to the state health department. It had stopped reporting these statistics for several weeks, so it was unknown if masks in schools had been ineffective before the current report. The Mackinac Center for Public Policy sent a Freedom of Information Act to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services requesting the school transmission rate information that was no longer being published.
The state health department says the fact that there are similar rates of transmission, regardless of masking requirements, is most likely due to community transmission outside of school. Even though the data suggests that masks do not stop transmission in schools, the department still presses officials to require them.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Michigan Lawmakers Approve $1 Billion in New Corporate Subsidies
Their votes can be seen and tracked on a business subsidy scorecard
On their last day of voting on bills in 2021, members of the Michigan House and Senate approved $1 billion in new spending on selective, taxpayer-funded handouts to certain corporations. Their votes have been added to a business subsidy scorecard that has recorded individual lawmakers's votes on such handouts, going back to 2001.
Lawmakers often get pressured to spend taxpayer dollars on business subsidy programs even though these have been demonstrated to be ineffective at growing employment, unfair to companies that don’t recieve the same privilege, and expensive for taxpayers. But the lure of tantalizing headlines about business expansion has proved just too tempting for most politicians.
Reportedly, lawmakers were driven to this vote by headlines about Ford Motor Co.’s decision to build electric vehicle plants in Kentucky and Tennessee. After that announcement, some legislators here were also being approached by a small number of unnamed business executives who suggested subsidies would be needed to get them to locate facilities in this state. These elected officials aren’t saying who told them this, and some have even signed non-disclosure agreements that prohibit sharing any details.
It’s a contrast to the past three years, during which senators and representatives in the Michigan Legislature have rejected calls to authorize additional corporate subsidy programs. A comparatively modest $261 million in new corporate handouts have been approved by state legislators during the Whitmer administration, compared to $2.5 billion during Gov. Rick Snyder’s two terms. Over the past 20 years, lawmakers have approved $17.6 billion in business subsidies.
The latest $1 billion subsidy votes in the state House and Senate were bipartisan on both the “Yea” and “Nay” sides. The roll call votes have been added to the business subsidy scorecard, which shows how much lawmakers have approved, and who was on either side of each vote. See the results here.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Love CapCon?
The best way you can help support our work is to become a donor. Give monthly or one-time. What do you say — buy our reporters a cup of coffee?
Have a coffee on me! Already a supporter