News Story

Mask Mandates A Problem For Kindergartners

Legal complaint claims five-year-old children struggle under state health department order

A private Catholic school has filed a legal complaint over a state order that students from kindergarten to fifth grade wear face masks.

The complaint was filed Oct. 22 by the Church of the Resurrection school, which is located in Lansing. The complaint was filed against the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services and the Ingham County Health Department.

The school cited a particular kindergartner to show why the complaint was filed. The child is said to be shy and the face mask hinders her ability to be heard, socialize and acclimate to new surroundings. The student also has trouble pronouncing certain letters and wearing a face mask exacerbates her struggles and hinders her ability to learn, according to the school.

It is also difficult for the student to handle the face mask properly and it is difficult for her to keep it clean or from falling onto the floor.

She also has seasonal allergies for which she takes medication, and the face mask make it more difficult for her to breathe, the school said.

On Oct. 29, the school took to Facebook to further clarify the problem and the solution it seeks.

“We are NOT contesting masks for teachers, older students in classrooms, or younger students when they are in a mixed groups,” The school posted on Facebook. “But we are contesting masks for younger children when socially distanced in their own classrooms.”

Lynn Sutfin, spokeswoman for the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, said the state’s order is lawful.

“MDHHS is confident that that the epidemic order is lawful,” Sutfin said in an email. “MDHHS Director Robert Gordon issued the order under a different law than the law invalidated by the Michigan Supreme Court. The law under which Director Gordon acted was enacted by the Michigan Legislature specifically to deal with epidemics.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Bite

State Mandates Businesses Collect Customer Info - And No Sweat If It's Bogus

No need to confirm names on required contact tracing list aren't really Mickey and Minnie

Under a new state "contact tracing" mandate imposed on Michigan businesses, firms have no duty to verify that the contact information they must collect from patrons is correct, and are not required to deny entry to customers who refuse to cooperate.

That’s what a "Frequently Asked Questions" post on a state website says about the mandate imposed by Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, effective Nov. 2.

The state "encourages" establishments to deny entry to individuals who refuse to provide their name and contact information. Businesses are also asked to collect information from everyone at a table, including parental information for minors. But the FAQ document says it is acceptable to collect contact information just from the head of the household.

The order does not affect just restaurants and bars. According to the FAQ the mandate extends to: "Barbering, cosmetology services, body art services (including tattooing and body piercing), tanning services, massage services, or similar personal care services; Recreational sports and exercise facilities, and entertainment facilities (except for outdoor, non-ticketed events), including arenas, cinemas, concert halls, performance venues, sporting venues, stadiums and theaters, as well as places of public amusement, such as amusement parks, arcades, and bingo halls; all businesses or operations that provide in-home services, including cleaners, repair persons, painters; all dine-in food service establishments, including bars and restaurants."

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Bite

Washington State Contact-Tracing Mandate Rebuffed By ACLU, Rescinded; Michigan Version Stands

In May, Washington Gov. Jay Inslee required businesses to obtain contact information from their customers so that state officials could conduct contact tracing should COVID-19 outbreaks develop.

The ACLU of Washington protested the measure, and Inslee quickly retracted the mandate.

“We have serious concerns with any plan that would require people to disclose their names and/or contact information and whereabouts without strict controls on the storage and accessibility of such information,” the ACLU of Washington state wrote. “Normally, judicial oversight or, at a minimum, informed consent would be required to allow others to access and use personally identifying information and related data about travel and association with others. Business logs cannot be susceptible to disclosure beyond the tightly limited purposes of contact tracing. Without appropriate safeguards, contact information can be disclosed to immigration agents, law enforcement, advertising companies, identity thieves, stalkers, and harassers. If providing contact information is mandatory, rather than voluntary, this may have the effect of excluding people from public accommodations for fear of nonconsensual data sharing and other forms of surveillance abuses.”

Michigan’s Department of Health and Human Services issued a similar requirement for state businesses, effective Nov. 2.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.