Commentary

Michigan’s arbitrary process for banning license plates

Government prohibits words for products it advertises

If you drive down I-75, you’ll see dozens of billboards advertising marijuana, alcohol and late-night clubs.

But if you own a brewery and want to celebrate your wares, you can’t get a vanity license plate that says “BEER” or “12PACK” or anything to do with alcohol. The same goes for drugs, including marijuana (the “House of Dank” is advertised on a billboard, but “DANK” on a license plate is out).

The state of Michigan uses 25 volunteers to determine which vanity license plates are verboten. Volunteers and the state have banned 25,000 words or expressions in an exercise that requires making all sorts of moral decisions on the public’s behalf.

The process is arbitrary.

If you paid attention during the last gubernatorial election in Michigan, you probably remember the motto of one candidate (and current governor): “fix the damn roads.” But while that can appear in campaign ads and every media platform, the Secretary of State volunteers don’t allow “damn” on state license plates. No “DAMLADY,” no declaring that you are “DAMFAST” and definitely no “DAMKIDS.”

O.J. Simpson died recently, but if you think you can use a license plate to express your opinion on his criminal case, think again. “OJDIDIT” is banned.

The state itself advertises Michigan’s beer and wine producers in its Pure Michigan campaign. But good luck getting a “H0PS” or “WHISKY” license plate. Even “DR1NK” is a no-go.

Farmers place manure on their vehicles regularly. But they can’t get “MANURE” on their license plates. Go figure.

The state has no problem operating and advertising a gambling racket it calls the Michigan Lottery. But if you want to advertise your love of gambling with “BETTTT,” the cards are stacked against you.

The state says it will reject applications for personalized plates that:

  • Contain profanity or obscene language

  • Depict a swear word

  • Are sexually explicit or graphic

  • Describe intimate body parts or genitals

  • Describe alcohol, alcohol use, drugs, drug culture or drug use

  • Describe illegal activities or illegal substances

  • Interfere with plate identification for law enforcement purposes

  • Promote hate or violence to a business or group

Yes, most of the banned terms are vulgar and fall into one of the categories above. But many are not. Reading the list, I have no clue why some are banned, like “ZZZZZZ,” “XXXL” or “GRRR.”

This is just another example of the arbitrary and bizarre processes of government: banning things that government itself heavily promotes in other areas.

Reading this story, one’s inclined to blame the 25 darn “Karens” who make these decisions. That’s fine. Just don’t put “DAMKRN” on a vanity license plate. It will be rejected.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

State budget amendment would require apprenticeships for workers on state-funded projects

No obvious out for those who have already been working

The House Appropriations Committee Subcommittee on General Government added language to the 2025 Michigan budget to require skilled trades professionals to enroll in an apprenticeship program as a condition of working on state-funded projects.

The boilerplate language was added in section 228 of the budget. It reads: “Requires all construction, repair, or remodeling projects to be performed by individuals who have completed or are enrolled in a registered apprenticeship program.”

Under the language, anyone who has already worked on a state-funded project as a welder, plumber, electrician or in another capacity would not be able to work on a new project without having been registered in an apprenticeship program. This would apply even if a person had been doing that work for years.

Rep. Tom Kuhn, R-Troy, introduced an amendment to strike the language from the budget. The subcommittee rejected the amendment 6-3 on a party-line vote.

A representative of a contractors’ trade association said the proposal would have wide-ranging effects. “Under this proposal, every worker on a job site will need to be enrolled in a registered apprenticeship program, meaning the worker sweeping the floors, the worker picking up orange barrels along the road and the worker holding the slow/stop sign at each end of a road project needs to be a registered apprentice,” Shane Hernandez, president of Associated Builders and Contractors of Michigan, told CapCon in an email.

Hernandez continues, “The language included in the budget not only limits opportunities for apprentices in Michigan, but it goes a step further by penalizing workers who have dedicated decades to a construction trade, blocking them from a job site simply because they took a different route to enter the trades.

Hernandez says the budget language will result in increased costs, longer timelines for projects, and fewer opportunities for workers to get into the skilled trades.

Certain occupations are subject to state-imposed regulatory requirements for training and education, and many professional societies offer certification programs. These include the American Welding Society for welders and the ASSE for plumbers.

State-imposed requirements can keep some people out of certain occupations and reduce economic growth, scholars and regulatory experts said at an October 2023 conference held by the Mackinac Center.

“Regulatory and legal barriers to work cost America two million jobs each year,” Conor Norris, one of the participants, told the audience. Norris studies the labor market at West Virginia University.

The country suffers $7 billion in lost output and $185 billion in misallocated resources, he added.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.