Jaye: Triple-dippers are draining governments in Michigan
Michigan offers ‘golden handcuffs’ to longtime workers who want to retire, denying opportunities for advancement to younger ones
To the Editor:
The triple dippers program allows some public employees to triple dip, which is: to “retire” and start receiving their pensions and salaries at the same time to do the same job, while not paying 3% of their salary into the taxpayer-funded pension program, like every other public employee. (Former state senator takes a lick at triple dippers, May 6)
At the end of a five- or six-year term, the “public servant” will receive a pension cash bonus payout. Triple dippers cash out unused vacation, personal and sick leave at their final highest salary, not the salary when the unused days were earned, which artificially spikes their final year’s pay, on which pensions are based.
Triple dippers collect all pay increases, insurance benefits, bonuses and promotions during these five years then collect a taxpayer-paid pension and health benefits for life when they retire for the second time. Some triple dippers retire permanently, others continue working. Triple dippers are enrolled in the “Deferred Retirement Option Program.”
In Macomb County, 183 retired politicians and public employees are taking $13.4 million in salaries and $32.4 million in pension payments at the same time, to do the same job they'd been doing. This puts stress on public coffers.
Many triple dippers are non-core mission employees, including cooks, janitors, cashiers, 25 secretaries and a part-time van driver. See the full report on triple dippers in Macomb County. The highest cash bonus payout in Macomb County is $503,672, and 150 triple dippers take over $100,000. Some triple dippers are taking overtime more than 70% of their posted salary.
Taxpayers pay 43 Michigan State Police officers over $300,000, and seven more than $400,000, not to retire. Michigan State Police officers and secretaries get a full pension after 25 years in law enforcement, even if they are under age 50.
Michigan State Police Col. Kriste Kibbey Etue retired with a $502,000 pension bonus and a $91,920 annual pension. No private company allows such abuses.
Michigan State Police and the Sterling Heights police refuse to release the names of their police triple dippers.
Excessive taxpayer-paid pension cash bonuses are “golden handcuffs,” incentivizing senior officers who are burned out physically and mentally, who want to retire, to keep working. This denies younger, healthier, and better-educated officers opportunities to be promoted.
Instead of fattening the paycheck of overpaid, over-the-hill politicians and bureaucrats, we should replace triple dippers with young, freshly educated, and trained employees at entry-level salaries, saving approximately 40%, which could be spent on roads, seniors, veterans, and tax cuts.
Pressure your Macomb County officials and candidates for State Legislature and governor to outlaw triple dipping, require payment of 3% of salary into the pension program, and mandate that public employees who are convicted of felonies or misdemeanors of stealing from taxpayers shall lose taxpayer-paid pensions.
David Jaye is a former Michigan lawmaker and a researcher at tripledippers.org.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
How free are we really?
Nine hundred new laws are too many
Gov. Gretchen Whitmer recently said she worked in a bipartisan effort to sign into effect more than 900 new laws during her first term. She actually meant it as an accomplishment. And this is why one has to ask, “Just how free are we, really?” This is a question every citizen in the state should have asked after the circus of Michigan’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
There’s no doubt some laws are needed for the protection of citizens. Would you trust your drinking water if the plumbing was done by someone who figured out how to plumb using YouTube videos? Would you trust an amateur electrician to wire your house? Of course not.
So when do politicians and bureaucrats decide how much regulation is enough? Some of the punitive laws on the books suggest that the politicians themselves don’t know where to draw the line.
Do you want to pay your friend to cut your hair? Don’t let the government find out, or your friend could be charged with a misdemeanor. It takes 1,500 hours of training before the state will permit your friend to cut your hair for pay. What was the thought process behind this seemingly arbitrary number, or the decision to require the license at all? If I trust someone to cut my hair and that person screws it up, is this a life-threatening situation? Hair grows back, and that person would be out of a job. Problem solved.
Did your friend give you a great massage? That’s great for you! Just don’t pay your friend, because it takes 500 hours in Michigan to professionally massage another human. Why is the state regulating whom I choose to let rub my muscles?
The state will also use valuable time and money to protect the paint job on your house. Painters in the state are required to put in 10 times as many hours as auto mechanics to be legally allowed to paint your house. If your auto mechanic doesn’t do his job, you could lose your life. If your painter does a poor job you will lose a good view.
But don’t worry, the state isn’t here to just protect your skin, home decor and hair. It will also decide who is qualified to look after your children. After all, you are just the parent. Sweet Linda next door is a grandma who raised numerous kids and cared for her grandkids. She just adores your little Johnny and would be happy to watch him a few days a week while you work a part-time job. But she can’t. The state of Michigan would punish if she were paid to watch your child. You see, although she managed to keep her kids and grandkids alive, the state needs to give her a piece of paper and a list of rules to follow so she can keep your kids alive, too.
According to a study by Morris Kleiner at the University of Minnesota, it was reported in 2017 that regulations in Michigan cost 125,000 jobs per year. And the average family had to pay another $2,700 per year due to less competition. In fact, it was noted that Michiganders pay up to 30% more on licensed services than they otherwise would.
Perhaps lawmakers should make a law that for every law they make, they must repeal one. Such as Act 328 of 1931, “Punishment—Any man who shall seduce and debauch any unmarried woman shall be guilty of a felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison not more than 5 years or by fine of not more than 2,500 dollars; but no prosecution shall be commenced under this section after 1 year from the time of committing the offense.”
They could also look at the blasphemy and cursing laws that would probably now land the majority of citizens in hot water if it were enforced.
We all had a wake-up call when the COVID-19 pandemic struck and Gov. Gretchen Whitmer wielded all of the authority she could muster to keep stores from selling gardening seeds. Before the pandemic, even people knowledgeable about public policy did not realize there was a law that gave the governor so much authority. (The Michigan Supreme Court, thankfully, eventually ruled that law unconstitutional.)
Before the pandemic, most of us also didn’t know that health department bureaucrats could take over those powers after they were stripped from the governor — and still enforce her edicts. A lot of people lost their livelihoods as a result.
So when the same governor who told you that you cannot use your boat if it has a motor brags about a bipartisan effort to usher in 900 new laws, every citizen should sit up, take notice, and ensure that more of our freedoms are not being eroded.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Follow us on social media!
Push back on big government “solutions” by becominga fan of us on Facebook and X. Plus you can share free-market news to your network!
Facebook
I already follow CapCon!
More From CapCon