Editorial

Detroit Teacher Sickout Strike Causes 80 Percent of Students to Miss School

At least 34,000 students harmed by walkout

About eight out of every 10 Detroit Public School students have been impacted by the series of sickouts their teachers have imposed upon the district.

According to a Mackinac Center analysis, there have been 34,490 students impacted by the sickouts. The district has 42,356 students in grades K-12 in 2015-16, according to the state of Michigan. The analysis was based on the reporting of the Detroit Free Press on the number of schools closed due to the string of sickouts that date back to December of this school year.

“The illicit sickout action in Detroit is mushrooming out of control, now having affected more than 30,000 students,” said Ben DeGrow, the education policy director for the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. “How many of those students’ families must be wondering what it would take to get into one of the city’s charter schools or private schools that remain open today?”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

State Legislature Looking to Address Detroit School Sickouts

Chairman of education committee criticizes 'ridiculous antics'

The chair of the State Senate Education Committee said state legislators are looking at how to address the series of sickouts staged by Detroit Public School teachers who are upset about plans by Gov. Rick Snyder to completely revamp the troubled school district.

Detroit Public Schools Spokeswoman Michelle Zdrodowski didn’t respond to questions about how many schools had been closed due to sickouts. The media reported that five schools recently had been closed in one week.

The Detroit News reported that Steve Conn, who was the president of the Detroit Federation of Teachers before being removed, was taking credit for the sickouts.

“These ridiculous antics are simply so-called adults depriving schoolchildren of valuable instruction time,” said Sen. Phil Pavlov, R-St. Clair Township, who is chair of the Senate's education committee, in an email. “They are clearly deliberate and coordinated efforts to shut down schools, and they absolutely merit the Legislature’s attention. In fact, we are looking right now into the legal definitions of strike conditions and other potential measures to address this situation.”

Sen. Rick Jones, R-Grand Ledge, said he would support a bill that addressed sickouts by teachers that close schools.

“They are not supposed to strike,” Jones said. “They get around not striking by a sickout. So perhaps there needs to be a change in the law in that area.”

While the sickouts are considered illegal strikes by some legal experts, the process is cumbersome to enforce under existing laws. The law states that before a public employer may discipline a public employee for engaging in a strike, the public employee has a right to a hearing.

With a large school district, that can lead to hundreds upon hundreds of hearings. For example, media reports have listed as many as a dozen DPS schools that have been closed due to sickouts in December and January. There are more than 460 teachers at those schools cited.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

Detroit District Teachers Stage Sickout; Charter Teachers Go to Work

Job action raises question about priorities

While more than 6,000 children in Detroit Public Schools have recently been shut out of their classrooms because teachers are staging sickout strikes, charter school students can still attend their classes.

“It’s a shame that children in Detroit are being used as political pawns by the adults,” said Dan Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public School Academies, the state's association of public charter schools. “Thousands of students are being kept out of class because of these selfish actions, and parents should be furious. This isn’t happening at charter schools, and it’s no surprise that charter schools are as popular as they are in Detroit.”

While public schools in Michigan are unionized, just six of the 302 charter schools in the state have teacher unions.

Two schools in DPS were closed Friday because teachers called in sick: East English Village Preparatory Academy and Mann Learning Community. Earlier in the week, Cass Tech High School, King High School and Renaissance High school were also closed due to sickouts. The total enrollment of the five schools that had to close is 6,949; statistics from the Michigan School database from the Mackinac Center for Public Policy suggests that actual attendance is 6,162.

Teachers have been protesting a number of issues. Among the most significant is Gov. Rick Snyder’s plan to split the district into two parts. Also, the teachers want DPS to revert to local control (it has been under state oversight since 2009) and receive more funding from the state.

Before Friday's sickouts took place, Rep. Tim Kelly, R-Saginaw, chair of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on School Aid, publicly called on State Superintendent Brian Whiston to impose sanctions on the striking teachers.

“This is selfish behavior and a blatant attempt to circumvent the law barring the Detroit Federation of Teachers membership from walking away from their responsibilities and striking,” Kelly said. “I’m encouraging Mr. Whiston to look at all available options in sanctioning the DFT.”

“These actions by certain DPS teachers [do] absolutely nothing to address or correct the problems tied to the district,” Kelly added. “All it’s doing is damaging the education of thousands of students.”

On Friday, Kelly said that Whiston has assured him that he is looking into the situation.

The Detroit Federation of Teachers didn't respond to a request for comment.

The union has publicly taken the stance that it is not involved with the sickout strikes. Ivy Bailey, the DFT's interim president, told Frank Beckman of WJR-AM on January 7 that she “personally” hoped there wouldn’t be more strikes. She also said, “the teachers were advocates for the children" and there needs to be “a major investment in Detroit kids and their future.”

Kelly said on the Beckman show on January 8 that he believes the best prospect for the kids of Detroit is to “turn them loose and let them go to where they can best be served; that would include, I think, private schools and charter schools.”

He also said the strikes aren’t helping the teachers’ cause.

“They only dissipate any kind of support they have in Lansing,” Kelly said.

Meanwhile, the children in Detroit who are enrolled in charter schools are still able to pursue their education each school day.

“Charter schools are truly making a difference,” Quisenberry said. “There’s an important discussion that needs to take place about education in Detroit, and it isn’t helping matters when selfish adults are putting their needs first.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.