News Story

Bye-bye Prevailing Wage Law? Repeal Campaign Turns In 390,000 Signatures

Just 252,523 needed to force up or down vote in Legislature

A coalition organized to repeal the state’s prevailing wage law achieved a milestone yesterday when it submitted petitions with more than 390,000 signatures to the state elections bureau. If at least 65 percent of those signatures were deemed to be valid signatures of Michigan voters, the question would then go to the Legislature for a quick up or down vote.

“Nearly 400,000 voters have signed their names on the dotted line to demand that government spend their tax dollars more wisely,” said Chris Fisher, in a news release. Fisher is vice president of Protecting Michigan Taxpayers, the coalition organizing the campaign. He is also president of the Associated Builders and Contractors of Michigan trade group.

“Taxpayers’ message couldn’t be clearer,” Fisher added. “It’s time to repeal the prevailing wage law costing our schools and communities millions.”

Michigan’s prevailing wage law prohibits public schools, the state and local governments from awarding construction contracts to the lowest bidder unless the contractor agrees to pay wages based on union pay scales on the project. It is estimated the prevailing wage law costs Michigan taxpayers $224 million annually.

The next step will be for the elections bureau to examine the signatures. Just 252,523 validated signatures are needed, far less than the number submitted. Should organizers pass that test, the state Board of Canvassers would be required to qualify the measure as citizen initiated legislation. That means the Legislature would have to take a vote on the measure within 40 days. If lawmakers fail to pass the measure, it would be placed before the voters on the November 2016 statewide ballot.

“Michigan construction workers are now one step closer to full equality in government contracting,” said Vincent Vernuccio, the director of labor policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. “That also means that Michigan taxpayers are now one step closer to real market savings.”

Both the GOP-controlled House and Senate have made repealing the prevailing wage law a priority. Reportedly, the repeal coalition pursued the initiated-law process to avoid a possible gubernatorial veto. Under this process, once either voters or the Legislature approves the repeal the governor has no role, because his signature is not required for it to become law.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Economic Freedom of the World Index: America’s Worrisome Decline

The U.S. ranks 16th in economic freedom

The “Economic Freedom of the World Index” published by the Fraser Institute of Canada measures the degree to which the world’s 157 nations and territories permit voluntary, peaceful economic exchanges between their own citizens and with people in other countries. The most recent index has just been released, and based on data from 2013, it ranks the United States 16th in economic freedom.

Given this country’s history and traditions, America should be far and away No. 1; that fact that it does not hold the top slot is yet more evidence of how governance has gone off track in this country in recent years.

The index is based on five major categories of data: the size of the government; the strength of the legal system, including property rights;  the soundness of the local currency; the freedom to trade with other nations; and economic regulations. Within these categories are more than 40 variables, such as “government consumption as a share of total consumption” (in the “size of government” category) and “inflation: most current year” (in the “sound money” category). Each variable gets a score. All the scores within a category are converted into an average score for the category, and the categories are averaged together to give a country’s overall score. The highest possible score is 10.

The overall score for the U.S. is 7.73, down 0.9 points since 2000. This decline may seem small, but the index’s authors observe that it is three times the average decline among the top-20 nations that comprise the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, the largest and most diversified economies in the world. More important for real people, our decline is reflected in the real-world consequence of slower economic growth, which means less opportunity for all Americans.

America’s declining economic liberty goes against a worldwide trend of growing freedom. In 1980 the average freedom index score for nations appearing in the index was 5.31. As of 2013 the world average stands at 6.86. According to the authors, the U.S. was ranked first among OECD nations from 1970 through 2000 (and in about third place if Hong Kong and Singapore were added to that list).

Since then our decline has been precipitous. It also portends a slower economic growth rate than Americans have been accustomed to, as much as half of the three percent annual growth we once enjoyed.

Some of the 15 nations that outperformed the U.S. in the current index may surprise you. They include, ranked from highest to lowest: Hong Kong, Singapore, New Zealand, Switzerland, United Arab Emirates, Mauritius, Jordan, Ireland, Canada, United Kingdom, Australia, Georgia, Chile, Qatar and Taiwan.

Good for them, but honestly: Georgia, Jordan, UAE and Qatar? How low the mighty have fallen to be surpassed by such recently benighted polities.

For example, just 25 years ago Georgia was the “Georgian Soviet Socialist Republic,” its people chained by the dead hand of communist central planning, coercion and corruption. On a more hopeful note, if even Georgia can throw off its chains, then surely the U.S. can unwind the damage done by 15-plus years of bad federal policies.

This is a vital task, because economic freedom correlates with so many of the things people value, not the least of which is material well-being. Per capita personal income for countries in the bottom 25 percent of the index averages less than $7,000, while average annual incomes in the highest quartile all exceed $38,600. Those who imagine this to be just coincidence might consider investing their retirement nest eggs in Venezuela, Republic of Congo or Libya, the three least-free nations economically.

The Fraser Institute also publishes economic freedom indexes for the states and provinces of Canada, Mexico and the U.S., with the 2015 edition coming out later this year. In last year’s index, using data through 2012, Michigan was a mediocre 37th among the 50 states, up from a dismal 45th place in 2009. It will be interesting to see how the Great Lake State fares in rankings assembled after its right-to-work law went into effect in 2013.

Empirical evidence shows that economic liberty and human well-being are highly correlated. If the world’s policymakers were to govern on this basis, world poverty would be reduced and the untold human tragedies associated with subsistence-level existence would be that much fewer.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.