News Story

Why Do Michigan Residents Falsely Believe Education Spending Is Down?

'If you repeat a lie long enough, people begin to believe it'

In three of her last four budgets, Gov. Jennifer Granholm cut state funding to K-12 schools.

In Gov. Rick Snyder's first four budgets, he has increased state funding to K-12 schools, up to a record $12 billion in 2014-15, according to the Senate Fiscal Agency.

So how is Gov. Snyder being tagged by critics as the villain who has cut funding to school children?

The answer lies in how the complicated nature of school funding has been the most misunderstood story reported in the media, as well as a campaign to portray schools as underfunded.

“If you repeat a lie long enough, people begin to believe it,” said Charles Owens, state director of the National Federation of Independent Business. “The MEA and other apologists for the previous administration continue to repeat that lie. A lot of school superintendents continue to repeat that lie. And it’s a lie because it doesn’t consider total funding.”

As of March, a Denno-Research poll showed that many Michigan residents believed that Snyder cut funding. When asked, “In the three years that Governor Rick Snyder has been in office, do you think he overall has increased or decreased spending for K-12 schools?” 53.8 percent of the people polled said they thought he decreased spending on K-12 schools. Just 18 percent thought Gov. Snyder had increased spending and 24 percent either didn’t know, were unsure or refused to answer.

Gary Naeyaert, executive director of the Great Lakes Education Project, pointed out that Gov. Granholm had $2 billion a year in federal funds in her final three budgets from 2008-09 to 2010-11. Gov. Snyder has seen federal support drop since taking office and has never had more than $1.8 billion in federal support in a year.

“She cut state funding and replaced it with federal temporary stimulus funds that everyone knew was going to end,” Naeyaert said. “Snyder lost federal funds and replaced it with state funds. And he’s the bad guy.”

The MEA school employee union has started a website that claims to show how “Snyder’s school cuts have hurt your district.” It cites the Michigan Department of Education as a source.

But the numbers don’t add up.

For example, the MEA’s site states that Armada Area Schools lost $2.8 million total from 2011-12 to 2014-15 by comparing how much funding has been lost each of those years compared to 2010-11. The MEA highlighted the district in its magazine when Democratic gubernatorial candidate Mark Schauer made a campaign visit to the district.

But according to the MDE, the Armada district has received more money from the state in each of the three years that Gov. Snyder controlled the budget, despite a decrease in students. Armada received $13.5 million in 2010-11, which was Gov. Granholm’s last budget. The district received $13.7 million in 2011-12 and 2012-13. It took in $13.8 million in 2013-14.

But even Schauer concedes that Michigan schools are getting more money from the state. In the August issue of the MEA Voice magazine, an article claims Gov. Snyder has cut $2.8 billion from schools compared to 2011. However, Schauer is quoted in the article saying schools are getting more.

"With most Michigan schools getting about 29 cents more per pupil per school day, at the current rate of inflation, this means districts will actually get less in next year's budget than they did this year," Schauer said.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Flanagan Goes too Far on Charter Schools

State TTB ranking a proxy for poverty

Just one out of every two entering high school freshmen manage to graduate from Pontiac Public Schools, a rate lower than the vast majority of Michigan conventional districts and charter public schools. And Pontiac's finances are just as bad as its academic performance: The district is overspending by close to $40 million per year.

Despite these failings, the Michigan Department of Education has allowed Pontiac to remain open. No Pontiac school has been closed for poor academic performance. And earlier this year, State Superintendent Michael Flanagan allowed Pontiac to take an entire decade to clean up its spending, even though state law requires districts to eliminate their deficits within two years.

These actions stand in stark contrast to the hard line Flanagan is taking on public charter schools. MDE has just announced that Flanagan is threatening to stop 11 charter public school authorizers from offering new schools:

  • Detroit Public Schools
  • Eastern Michigan University
  • Education Achievement Authority
  • Ferris State University
  • Grand Valley State University
  • Highland Park Schools
  • Kellogg Community College
  • Lake Superior State University
  • Macomb Intermediate School District
  • Muskegon Heights Public Schools
  • Northern Michigan University.

The charter school authorizers Flanagan is threatening to stall include some of Michigan's best. Indeed, just a year ago, MDE recognized Grand Valley State University and Lake Superior State University as the best charter school authorizers in the state.

According to MDE's press release, these charter authorizers are being targeted in part because of their schools' rankings on the state "Top-to-Bottom" list. The Center has repeatedly criticized the state ranking system for being a proxy for poverty — meaning that by using this measure, Flanagan is penalizing schools that take in students from low-income backgrounds.

And yet, even if the department prioritizes TTB rankings, it is unfairly penalizing charter schools. Some of the worst-scoring schools on the list are conventional schools. Indeed, about 50 schools have been ranked among the bottom 5 percent of Michigan schools for the past three consecutive years. Only four were charter public schools, and three of those four schools have been closed.

Inexplicably, state officials continue to ignore the best study on Michigan charter schools. Stanford University found that Michigan charter school students learn two extra months of material every year compared to their conventional school counterparts. No other study in Michigan has come close to Stanford's rigor, and attempts to characterize charter school performance as poor lack substantiation.

The best evidence suggests that unwarranted limitations on charter school growth will harm student academic outcomes. And, if authorizers are prevented from opening new charter schools, some of Michigan's most struggling students will be underserved.

Nowhere is this clearer than at Covenant House Academy, a charter school serving students struggling with homelessness, past expulsions, pregnancy or a criminal record. GVSU recently authorized Covenant House to open a school in Grand Rapids, enrolling 150 students this year.

And with GVSU's help, Covenant House Executive Director Sam Joseph is opening another school in Muskegon this fall. If the state superintendent stops allowing GVSU to authorize charter schools, he will be blocking future schools like these and the students they hope to serve.

State officials are ignoring the best evidence on Michigan charter school performance. Worse, they are specifically targeting charter schools while letting conventional districts, like Pontiac, continue to fail their students.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.