News Story

Some School Districts and Unions Embrace Right-to-Work

Pewamo-Westphalia and Hamilton put worker freedom into union contracts

While more than 100 school districts rushed to approve new contracts that impeded implementation of right-to-work before the March 27 deadline, at least two districts took a different approach.

Pewamo-Westphalia Community Schools and Hamilton Community School district embraced the concept of allowing its teachers a choice to join a union as a condition of their employment.

Both districts approved new teachers’ union contracts before the right-to-work law took effect, but had specific language in their agreements that allowed teachers to opt out of their union.

Hamilton Community Schools did it through a memo-of-understanding.

"It was important to me and the board that we honored what the intent of what that law was," said David Tebo, superintendent of Hamilton Community Schools, which is located in Allegan County. "My union didn’t dig their heels in. They understood where we were. It was never a point of contention. It was important to our union that publically we did the right thing and nobody was yelling and screaming about it.

"We are not a high profile district. We are not taking stands on issues that are politically charged," Tebo said.

Jason Mellema, superintendent of Pewamo-Westphalia in Clinton County, said the union leadership was 100 percent behind allowing right-to-work as an option for its teachers.

The new P-W teachers’ contract says: "No bargaining unit member is required to become or remain a member of the Association as a condition of employment."

"It's not a 'me' thing or a 'them' thing, but it's about us," Mellema said in an email. "We have had very good conversations about how to work together to solve problems. P-W is not perfect, and we (union leaders and myself) may not always agree on the solution to every challenge, but at the end of the day I know these people care about kids.

"Just my opinion, but if everyone in education learned to work together, we wouldn't have to rely on politicians or those who have never worked our field making decisions for us," Mellema said. "Unfortunately in education — teachers, support staff, administrators — we have all contributed to the challenges we face. Too many times in the past I've seen the different sides argue and fight instead of focusing on how to solve problems."

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

What Do Moms Want? School Choice

New survey shows large support for tuition tax credits

Perhaps the best thing state legislators could do for Michigan moms would be to allow more educational options for children  at least according to the latest poll from the Friedman Foundation.

Mothers polled supported all varieties of school choice, including providing students with resources to attend public, private or religious schools.

Mothers of school-age children were surveyed by phone and asked whether they supported specific school choice programs. Nearly 70 percent of moms said that they support tax credit scholarships for students. 

When asked about school vouchers, 66 percent of surveyed moms said that they supported them, with just 26 percent opposed. Mothers were much more supportive of vouchers than people who do not have children. Among different demographic groups, low-income earners and African Americans were some of the most supportive of school vouchers.

Moms also support universal eligibility for school choice: Two-thirds of surveyed moms support providing vouchers to all students, while just a third support limiting eligibility by income level. Young adults and African Americans were the demographic groups that were most supportive of universal eligibility. Republicans and independents were also supportive, while Democrats were less so.

It's hard to miss the educational establishment's fear of giving parents more control of where to educate their children. After all, public school officials started a lobbying organization with taxpayer money in order to oppose similar school reform measures. And officials have a vested interest (to put it bluntly, a paycheck) in preserving the existing system. But instead of worrying about the educational establishment’s latest email blast, legislators should pay attention to the opinions of those that our public education system is truly meant to serve.

Overall, moms of school-age children are supportive of school choice. Why not give them and their children more options? Brunch and flowers are nice for Mother’s Day, but a more lasting gift would be one that helps moms’ kids attend a school that best serves their needs.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.