News Story

State Has Weak History of Punishing School Campaign Finance Law Violators

Past school districts that broke the law received only $100 fine

To promote a $100 million bond proposal, the Secretary of State found that Traverse City Area Public Schools violated state campaign finance law by urging voters to support it.

However, if the Secretary of State stays true to its history of enforcement, it's likely the district will receive a slap on the wrist.

In 2011, Michigan Capitol Confidential looked at the Secretary of State's enforcement of school districts it found to have violated the campaign finance law from 2006 to 2010. The state fined two districts that broke the law $100 each.

The department and district have to reach a resolution within 90 days from Thursday or the case will be forwarded to the Attorney General's office, said Fred Woodhams, spokesman for the Secretary of State office. The Secretary of State has also asked the Traverse City school district to provide more information by May 6.

"The penalty could range from simply agreeing to not commit the violation again to fines,” Woodhams said. "We are cognizant that taxpayer funds have already been misused so requiring a public body funded by taxpayers to pay a fine in addition is something that requires careful deliberation on a case-by-case basis."

The department has asked the school district to provide additional information by May 6. The department and district will have to reach a resolution within 90 days from Thursday or it will be forwarded to the Attorney General’s Office.

Leon Drolet, chairman of the Michigan Taxpayers Alliance, said the state has to start fining individuals so it doesn't cost taxpayers double.

Drolet said the $100 fine sends the wrong message. The law states that the fine can be up to $1,000 for an individual and up to $20,000 for a school district.

"When the fine is that low, you are encouraging people to break the law," Drolet said. "That is a deliberate signal to not take the law seriously."

Jason Gillman, a tea party activist, filed the complaint with the state over a brochure the school district distributed.

The brochure read: "Traverse City Area Public Schools is asking voters to support the continuation of TCAPS' long-term capital infrastructure improvement plan by authoring a bond proposal on November 6, 2012."

The bond was defeated by voters.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

"Nicky's Family"

The inspiring story of Sir Nicholas Winton

I recently spent 96 mesmerizing minutes viewing the latest film release of the story of Sir Nicholas Winton at the Detroit Film Theatre within the Detroit Institute of Arts complex. “Nicky’s Family” (http://www.menemshafilms.com/nickys-family) portrays the bold actions of a young British businessman who saved 669 Jewish children from almost certain death in the days before World War II broke out on Sept. 1, 1939.

The story of determination is amazing. The story of a humble man is inspiring. I am sure some in the theatre were learning of Nicky’s actions for the first time. The film shares the story of 1939 in clips and through interviews of many of those 669 precious souls saved. It weaves around these clips the horror of the separation of parents and children as well as the concentration camps that followed for many of those same parents. It also portrays the modern day Nicholas Winton, who turns 104 next month and still maintains his own home — and has a decided glint in his eye. Surely the folks learning of his long ago deeds left the theater with admiration and thanks in their hearts.

We at the Mackinac Center first learned of Nicky when then-President Lawrence W. Reed met and interviewed him. For more of this remarkable story please read www.mackinac.org/8160.

For some of us, this is a more personal story. I will be forever grateful that I have met Nicky. I have been a guest in his home. I have waved a Union Jack with him in a box at the famed Royal Albert Hall as we listened to some of the most awe-inspiring music ever written. In addition, I have met three of those 669 in three different countries of the many they now inhabit. Yes, to me it is a very personal story.

“Nicky’s Family” is a story of triumph. Triumph over tyrants. Triumph of freedom which means everything to many of us. The children saved and their descendants now number more than 5,700. These people, down to the young grandchildren, have been contributors to our society and have done amazing things. Many feel the need to emulate Sir Nicholas Winton in doing good works wherever they are needed.

Thanks must be given to writer director Matej Minac for once again bringing this story to the big screen. His documentary, “Nicholas Winton: The Power of Good,” tells more of this incredible man. It and “Nicky’s Family” are both narrated by Joe Schlesinger of CBC fame. He too has a personal view of Nicky and his goodness. Yes, he was one of the saved children.

Unfortunately, “Nicky’s Family” is in limited release. But no matter how far you must drive to see this movie it will be decidedly worth every mile.

Some people make sweeping statements. Others live them. From a letter written in 1939 by Sir Nicholas Winton:

….there is a difference between passive goodness and active goodness which is, in my opinion, the giving of one’s time and energy in the alleviation of pain and suffering. It entails going out, finding and helping those in suffering and danger and not merely leading an exemplary life, in the purely passive way of doing no wrong.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.