Contracting Helps Cash-Strapped City Add More Police Officers For Less Money — And Better Service
Emergency manager action 'best thing that has happened in the city of Pontiac in a long time'
For eight consecutive years, the city of Pontiac broke the law by spending more for police services than it budgeted.
According to the city records, Pontiac violated the State Budget Act from 2002 to 2009 and was part of the reason why an emergency financial manager was appointed in 2009.
In August 2011, Emergency Manager Lou Schimmel worked out an arrangement where the Oakland County Sheriff’s Office took over as provider of police services for Pontiac.
The sheriff’s office brought in the existing 50 Pontiac police officers and re-hired 13 other former Pontiac police officers who had been laid off, and added 11 sheriff’s deputies to patrol the city.
The result was not just an extra 24 officers, but the transition saved $4.2 million while response time to calls dropped from 76 minutes under the Pontiac police to 9 minutes, 45 seconds under the Sheriff’s Department.
Pontiac spent $13.7 million on police services in 2009. That dropped to $9.5 million in 2011.
“Whatever services the city was providing before were high cost without high quality,” said James Hohman, a fiscal policy analyst with the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. “Governments across the state have the power to do a better job with the taxpayer money they receive. Residents should be skeptical when local officials threaten service cuts to justify tax increases.”
Bob Daddow, Oakland County Deputy Executive, said in an email the county was able to absorb many of the clerical and other costs that were used to hire more officers.
“The county absorbs the overhead costs as a good faith effort to assist local units in lowering their policing costs and think about it, we already had those functions with or without Pontiac,” Daddow said in an email. “In fact, because Pontiac gave up their dispatch system we actually can lower the county’s cost of maintaining their dispatch function now that it is rolled into the sheriff’s office.”
City officials applauded the transition.
“This is the best thing that has happened in the city of Pontiac in a long time,” Pontiac Mayor Leon Jukowski said in a press release. “It was the best decision for the community, the Pontiac officers, who are now sheriff’s deputies, and the entire city of Pontiac.”
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.
Love CapCon?
The best way you can help support our work is to become a donor. Give monthly or one-time. What do you say — buy our reporters a cup of coffee?
Michigan economic development agency gives former member $202M in grants
Michigan State Police lease first EV at $1,062 per month
Hill Harper and the problem of financial disclosure in Michigan
Is the Horseshoer on Strike?
Union employees from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department went on strike to protest a new plan that looks to right-size the entity through contracting and privatization. The workers are all a part of the local AFSCME union.
The department is one of the most inefficient government-run entities in the state. The DWSD currently takes in $715 million per year, but is nearly $6 billion in debt. At the same time, it has nearly twice as many employees per gallons of water as other major cities. A recent independent audit found that the department has 257 different job descriptions.
One of these job descriptions became famous last month after Michigan Capitol Confidential broke the story of the department having a horseshoer (or "farrier"), but not having any horses.
In sum, the local union is on strike to protect jobs — including jobs that apparently no longer have a purpose — in an entity that is among the most inefficient and in debt in the state.
Government entities should not be a jobs program, especially in a major city facing insolvency and struggling to provide services. Such a mindset ultimately harms all of us through higher taxes, worse services and the “crowding out” of the private sector. A better idea would be to sell or privatize this entity, just like many cities and countries around the world and even here in Michigan have done.
Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.