News Story

Green Eyeshadow On Red Ink: 'Green' Jobs Fail To Live Up To The Hype

Michigan invests billions, politicians' promises fail to materialize

In 2010, then-Gov. Jennifer Granholm touted the “energy economy” with helping turn around Michigan’s economy.

Granholm boasted that the state had 109,000 green jobs in 2009 and said, "The new energy economy is already here, infusing our state with good-paying, permanent jobs.”

From 2004 to 2009, Gov. Granholm said Michigan had invested $1 billion to promote “green manufacturing.”

Yet, green jobs account for just 2.1 percent of the total jobs in Michigan today, according to a government report.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics recently released a report that Michigan was 12th in the nation in providing jobs related to “green” energy. The report said Michigan had 79,771 green jobs, based on 2010 data.

There are 3.1 million jobs in the state, meaning those "green" jobs account for 2.1 percent of the total jobs in Michigan.

The BLS report also questions Gov. Granholm’s claim of 109,000 jobs.

Gov. Granholm didn’t respond to an email asking where she got her number of 109,000 green energy jobs, which is 37 percent higher than the BLS figure.

But James Hohman, a fiscal policy analyst with the Mackinac Center for Public Policy said the BLS report should open some eyes about how much of an impact green jobs have on the state’s total economy.

“The new BLS figures provide some context into whether politicians’ promises have translated into economic growth,” Hohman said in an email. “So far, green falls short of expectations. Subsidizing trendy industries at the expense of everyone else will hurt the state’s recovery.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Other Big State Universities Tighten Their Belts — U-M Has Much To Learn

The Wall Street Journal reports that tightening state budgets and declining state funds are forcing public universities to make choices in funding priorities.

Ohio State University is considering leasing their university-run parking lots and privatizing other assets “including two 18-hole golf courses, a small airport and a power grid.” The University of Kentucky and Portland State University are also instituting plans that would partially transfer dormitory operations to a private company.

The plan illustrates how "institutions don't have the resources they once did, and so they are trying to leverage every dollar possible," said Peter Eckel, vice president at the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges in the article.

The University of Michigan has complained of state appropriation cuts and President Mary Sue Coleman recently wrote a letter to President Obama asking for greater public support for higher education. Yet during a statewide and then nationwide recession, her university increased staff numbers and still enjoyed a skyrocketing boost in revenue. U-M also owns and operates two golf courses and spends an average of $129,000 per degree.

Other public universities in the state are not so cost-effective, spending $7,000 per degree above the national average.

Many politicians complain about high tuition rates at colleges and universities and often pursue political remedies that further entangle government and education. This ignores the point that subsidizing any industry often means a misallocation of resources. Just as a slight decrease in K-12 spending has meant greater efficiency in Michigan K-12 school districts, so budget trimming for higher education means a better use of those dollars.

When privatization is well-managed and not merely a front for sneaky forms of government borrowing, it generates better outcomes for government entities, including state universities and their students.

In contrast, defenders of an unsustainable state university status quo call to mind Ronald Reagan’s refrain: “Government is not a solution to our problems, government is the problem.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.