News Story

Are Teachers With Master's Degrees Forced To Take Food Stamps?

MEA fact check

The president of the Michigan Education Association claims he talked to a teacher with a master’s degree who was eligible for a Bridge card.

Steve Cook, the MEA’s president, said that a teacher he talked to was in his second year and had a master’s degree and made $31,000 a year.

The problem? Publically available data of salaries for each district doesn’t back Cook’s claim. Cook didn’t respond to an email requesting the school district that paid a full-time, second-year teacher with a master’s degree $31,000 a year.

The Michigan Association of School Boards reported in 2011 that a first-year teacher with a bachelor’s degree had an average salary of $36,798.

Michael Van Beek, education policy director of the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, looked at the five public school districts with the lowest average teacher salaries, according to the 2009-10 Michigan Department of Education Bulletin 1014.

Van Beek checked the teacher’s contracts and found salaries for second-year teachers with master’s degrees ranging from $34,385 to $35,140. The five school districts were Eau Claire, Fennville, Colon, Climax-Scott and Mendon.

And many of those teachers won’t stay at those salaries for long with step-increases included in their contracts. For example, a teacher at Eau Clair in his or her second year with a master’s degree made $34,385 and that included a 6-percent step increase from the previous year.

However, in higher paying districts, second-year teachers with a master’s degree can make much more than $31,000 a year. For instance, in Grosse Pointe, a second year teacher with a master’s degree makes $52,265. In River Rouge, that teacher makes $50,522.

Cook wrote that, “in recent years, Lansing politicians have pushed many school employees — maybe your child's teacher — right out of the middle class and into the ranks of the working poor.”

The average teacher’s salary in Michigan is $63,024, according to the Michigan Department of Education.

Cook also wrote: “When a professional with a master's degree is eligible for a Bridge Card — Michigan's version of welfare assistance — something has gone terribly wrong."

Van Beek said salary is not the only consideration when determining someone’s poverty status.

“Regardless of their base salary level, the claim that teachers are being pushed into poverty is dubious,” Van Beek said. “People living in poverty don’t have defined-benefit pensions, extravagant health care packages and three months paid vacation.”

Cook’s claim was not the first time an MEA representative has cried poor when discussing teacher’s salaries.

Ric Hogerheide, an MEA UniServe director, claimed that first-year teachers in the Lansing School District were paid below the poverty level in 2011. A first-year teacher with a bachelor’s degree earned $35,741 in 2009-10. That teacher would be below the U.S. Census Bureau’s poverty level if the teacher had a family of eight.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

News Story

Cutting Librarians and Therapists Would Save Prisons Millions

Senate Panel Finds $72.5 Million To Cut From Prison Administration

Shhh . . . keep it down.

A Michigan Senate committee has identified $5.6 million the state could save by cutting prison library staff.

“We found that some prisons have up to four library staff members,” said Sen. John Proos, R-St. Joseph, chair of the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on the Department of Corrections. “Overall, our budget would cut 52 library staff members from the state's prisons. That would bring a savings of $5.6 million.”

That $5.6 million represents only a fraction of the savings the subcommittee identified. On March 28, the Senate Appropriations Committee approved a 2013 budget that sliced $72.5 million from Gov. Rick Snyder's budget recommendation.

In addition to cutting prison library staffs, the committee found that $1.4 million in potential savings could be realized by eliminating music therapists and recreational therapists from prison budgets.

“There's just no way we can justify funding those positions,” Sen. Proos said, referring to the music and recreational therapists. “Prisons need to do more with less, just like the private sector does; and frankly, like most of our schools are doing.”

The highlight of the legislation (Senate Bill 0951) are $58.7 million in savings from reducing facility-level noncustodial (not involved with keeping prisoners in custody) staff by 580.

The largest portion of the $58.7 million in savings would be $32.1 million through elimination of 300 assistant resident unit supervisors. According to the findings of the committee, Michigan's prisons have adequate management personnel without the added layer these supervisors represent.

In addition to eliminating the assistant supervisors and librarians, other cost-saving cutbacks in the measure include:

  • Limiting each prison warden office to just one secretary — $12 million in savings
  • Limiting each prison to just one word processing expert — $2.5 million in savings
  • Limiting each prison to just one deputy warden — $3.1 million in savings
  • Limiting prisons to just one corrections inspector — $1.4 million

“Michigan’s prison populations have decreased by 8,000 in five years and we have closed 14 facilities, yet corrections still employs one-third of all state employees and their costs keep going up,” Sen. Proos said. “This budget is a step toward bringing Michigan’s costs in line with surrounding states. We have reduced unnecessary administration like multiple secretaries and word processing assistants, and we have been innovative enough to ensure taxpayers are getting the most value for their dollar.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.