News Story

Command Cops in Sterling Heights: $119k Average Pay — Demand Labor Arbitration in Dispute with City

A Sterling Heights police union with 35 members who averaged a gross salary of $119,000 this year and has refused to make any contract concessions — choosing instead to take the dispute to arbitration. The Sterling Heights Command Officers Association took a 3 percent pay cut last year, but balked when the city asked to extend the cut another year and requested an additional 4 percent cut, according to Sterling Heights City Manager Mark Vanderpool.

Without concessions, the city wants to impose a shortened work week on the police union, and this is what is going to arbitration. The hearing was Aug. 9 and a decision is expected within two months, Vanderpool said.

The Command Officers Association represents police sergeants, lieutenants and captains.  According to financial documents received from a Freedom of Information Act request, 34 of the 35 union members made $100,000 or more. The highest salary was $140,233.

The concessions are being sought because the city says it is losing millions in revenue. The city claims it has lost $27 million in property tax revenues the past four years because of declining property tax assessments and another $28.7 million in declining state revenue sharing over the last 10 years.

Meanwhile, four other city unions, and the firefighters union have accepted concessions, according to published reports. Vanderpool said seven of the city’s nine unions agreed to concessions.

A spokesman for the Command Officers Association could not be reached for comment.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Accountability 101: How’s Your Legislator Performing?

Here is the cumulative list of all MichiganVotes "Weekly Roll Call Report" votes for 2011These will be updated on a regular basis, and a new version started in 2012.

Every week MichiganVotes.org sends these reports to newspapers around the state, showing how just the state representatives and senators in their service area voted during the past week. They focus on the most politically revealing votes (what they do vs. what they say), plus the most important votes on matters of policy, and some that are just interesting. A cumulative list of all these votes is a useful reference source, if not a fully comprehensive one.

When scanning these votes, citizens should know that Republicans currently have a 26-12 majority in the state Senate, and 63-47 in the state House. The most politically revealing votes for accountability purposes are where some Republicans or some Democrats "break ranks" with their party; unanimous or party-line votes are much less revealing.

Partway through this year, the weekly reports posted on Mackinac.org (which being for a statewide audience do not include local legislators’ votes) began including links directly to each full roll call vote (see “Who Voted ‘Yes’ and Who Voted ‘No’”). Earlier in the year, the bill numbers were hot-links to a page with all legislative actions on the particular bill, among which are the links to “Who Voted ‘Yes’ and Who Voted ‘No.’"

To find out who your state senator is and how to contact him or her go here; for state representatives go here.

To create your own “scorecard” spreadsheet showing the votes of all legislators — along with a score generated by what you tell the site was the correct vote — go to “create a (free) account” on MichiganVotes, and when you log-on to it, go to “Update scorecards” in the drop-down menu that appears when holding the cursor over your username on the blue navigation bar.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

No State Favors For Fastest Growing Companies

Mlive recently reported that Inc. Magazine lists five of the top 500 fastest growing companies in America as Michigan-based:

  • No. 23  —  Trillacorpe Construction, Bingham Farms, $29.2 million in 2010 revenue;
  • No. 266  — Alliant Healthcare Products, Richland, $7.8 million;
  • No. 312  — Vigilant Technologies, Troy, $3.5 million;
  • No. 358  —  Dancin' Dogg Golf, Traverse City, $2.2 million;
  • No. 486  — Broadgate, Troy, $3.3 million.

    On a per-capita basis, this is not a strong performance for a state of nearly 10 million people, but a company's growth relies on more than just the population of its home state. More interesting is that none of the companies listed appear to have been selected by the state’s economic development agency for special favors. None have been granted selective MEGA tax breaks or subsidies, for example.

    Over the last decade, Michigan politicians went on a binge of picking corporate winners and losers for special state tax breaks and/or cash handouts (they passed 280 new laws categorized as "economic development"). But as these five firms demonstrate, who wins in the marketplace has little to do with who does or does not get selective government favors.

    Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.