News Story

State Law May Drive Job-Seeking Michigan Woman To Move Elsewhere

Lacking cosmetology license, she looks west for opportunity

Donna Williams grew up in Michigan, but is thinking about moving to Las Vegas because the licensing laws in her home state make it difficult for her to pursue her passion to work as a makeup artist.

Williams would like to work in a spa or salon but cannot because she doesn’t have the proper licenses the state requires. A widow who lives on a fixed income, Williams says it isn’t worth spending the time and money to get a cosmetology or esthetician license when all she wants to do is makeup.

The resident of White Pigeon moved to Burbank, California, for three months in 2009. She went there to study makeup artistry at the Westmore Academy of Cosmetic Arts with Marvin Westmore, who has worked on movies such as Blade Runner and Doctor Dolittle.

During her time in California, Williams received 480 hours of training in makeup and other skills required for working on movie sets, at weddings and at other locations. She also received training on airbrush makeup from Westmore’s daughter, Kandace.

Since returning to Michigan, Williams has worked as a makeup artist on film and video projects. She also has worked with photographers, and, to a limited extent, brides. Williams is currently working as a union apprentice with the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees. But after Michigan ended its film subsidy program, she said, there have been fewer film opportunities in the state.

Given that fewer film projects are available, Williams said she would like to do makeup in a spa or salon. But she can’t do that because she doesn’t have the occupational licenses required by the state.

“I’ve already spent $25,000 on my education,” Williams said. “I’d actually considered moving to Las Vegas because there’s a lot of shows out there, that you don’t need a license for.”

Williams faces a conflict between her desire to be in Michigan and her interest in using her training in her chosen field of work.

“I was born and raised in Michigan; of course I want to stay and use my talents in my home state, but my home state makes that almost impossible,” Williams said.

An applicant seeking a cosmetology license in Michigan must be at least 17 years old with a ninth grade education and have at least 1,500 hours of study at a licensed cosmetology school, or serve as an apprentice for more than two years in a licensed cosmetology establishment. The license also requires hundreds of dollars in fees and an exam.

An esthetician license, meanwhile, requires 400 hours of training, payment of a $200 fee and an exam.

While Williams has been able to do some makeup work on film projects and has volunteered at her local community theater, she has been discouraged by her inability to find a consistent 9-to-5 job.

Paul Avelar is an attorney for the Institute for Justice, a nonprofit law firm. He told Michigan Capitol Confidential he wonders why someone working as a cosmetologist or an esthetician needs a license in some circumstances, like in a salon, but not in others, like working with an independent producer on a film set.

“If it’s safe to do this in some contexts. Why isn’t it safe in other contexts?” Avelar asked. “This is again just another example of when states require a license for something that probably doesn’t need a license.”

All 50 states and the District of Columbia require a cosmetology license, according to the Institute for Justice, though their particular effects on makeup artists varies from state to state.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Analysis

For Each Gallon Of Water Michigan’s People Use, 288 Gallons Fall From The Sky

Really big-sounding water consumption figures appear much smaller when put in perspective

For every gallon of water consumed by Michigan’s residents and businesses, 288 gallons fall upon the state as rain, in an average year.

Since almost all of Michigan lies within the Great Lakes watershed, much of that rainfall makes its way into the lakes. From there it will eventually flow down the St. Lawrence River and into the Atlantic Ocean, or else evaporate into the atmosphere, to be replenished by new rainfalls.

According to the state, in 2015 about 187.7 billion gallons of water was consumed by Michigan’s people in their homes, farms, factories, businesses and electric power plants. That seems like a tremendous amount of water, but it appears much less so when compared to the amount of precipitation that falls on Michigan in an average year: 54.2 trillion gallons.

Here’s how those numbers look together:

     187,700,000,000
54,200,000,000,000

The gallons provided by rain is 288 times bigger than the amount of water used in Michigan.

The data for the calculations come from estimates provided by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality.

The department approved a permit on April 2 to allow Nestle to remove 200,000 gallons per day from a well in its Osceola County bottling plant. That act set off a new round of discussion and some activism on the issue of industrial and commercial use of the state’s water resources.

Politicians on both sides of the partisan divide and of all ideologies have weighed in as well.

State Rep. Peter Lucido, R-Shelby Township, recently posted on Facebook his concerns that wells would run dry.

“If so many groups are opposed to this increase as well as the ridiculous amount of water already being taken for basically free, why do our laws permit such a travesty to our most precious resource?” Lucido wrote.

“I am no environmental scientist but I did pay attention in science class and why you take upwards of 400 gallons per minute out of water system there is going to be major negative impact sooner than later on the ecosystem.”

However, water use numbers that may appear really big may look a lot smaller looking when put in perspective. Industry accounts for 13 percent of Michigan water consumption, and abundant water is one reason the auto industry grew up in this state instead of someplace like Texas. And water bottling, including Nestle’s operation, make up just 0.26 percent of industrial use here.

Nestle’s bottling operation used 1.1 million gallons of water per day in 2015, according to the MDEQ. U.S. Steel was the state’s largest industrial water user at 146.4 million gallons per day. Agriculture irrigation is the largest consumptive use of water in Michigan, accounting for 39 percent.

The state of Michigan considers the Great Lakes, surface water, and groundwater to be interconnected parts of a single hydrologic system. The well that Nestle uses is called White Pine Springs and is connected to the Great Lakes via Chippewa and Twin Creeks. Those creeks flow into the Muskegon River, which flows into Lake Michigan. It is estimated that Lake Michigan holds 1.3 quadrillion gallons of fresh water and the all of the Great Lakes hold an estimated 6 quadrillion gallons (6,000,000,000,000,000.)

Nestle is now permitted to use up to 73 million gallons a year at its facility in Evart Township in Osceola County. The township gets an average 32.73 inches of annual rainfall, which drops a total of 20.5 billion gallons of water upon it in a typical year.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.