News Story

District Refuses to Sell Unused Building to Public Charter School — Despite Receiving $250K Asking Price

Battle Creek Public Schools pays tens of thousands of dollars per year to maintain empty school

Battle Creek Public Schools turned down an offer of $250,000 for a closed school building that came from a charter public school.

Ron Hutchinson, CEO of The Foundation for Behavioral Resources, said the Augusta-based nonprofit was looking to open a charter elementary school and had offered to pay BCPS its full asking price for the former Southwestern Middle School. Battle Creek pulled the building off the market after receiving the charter school's bid.

The Foundation for Behavioral Resources decided to buy property in Kalamazoo instead, according to Tim Wood, the special assistant to the president for charter schools at Grand Valley State University — which authorized the charter school.

“They’ve given up on that Battle Creek location,” Wood said.

The decision to not sell the property has angered some in the community, especially since it has been closed since 2006.

A letter to the editor in the Battle Creek Enquirer from resident Brian Dukeman accused the district of not wanting to sell the property to the charter school for fear it would make them look bad if the school outperformed the conventional public schools “in your back yard.” Dukeman questioned how much it would cost to tear the school down.

The district stated it received an initial offer of $150,000 from The Foundation for Behavioral Resources and another offer of $195,000 from the First Salem Missionary Baptist Church. Hutchinson said his group increased its second bid to $250,000.

Battle Creek Public Schools Superintendent Linda Hicks said Tuesday in an email the decision with what to do with their property hasn’t been put on the agenda yet.

“We should be putting the information together so that we are able to discuss shortly,” Hicks wrote.

The district is still paying to maintain the property. Information received through a Freedom of Information Act request shows the district paid $36,833 in 2010 and $28,210 in 2011 to maintain the property.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.

Commentary

Taxpayers Fund Bureaucratic Back Slapping

Questionable spending by government is practically the rule rather than the exception, but some examples can make even jaded, long-time observers scratch their heads in wonder.

Here’s one: The Michigan Department of Natural Resources gives grants to many local governments for public recreation projects and programs. Last year more than $550,000 was expended by the state for this purpose, with the money coming from the voluntary $10 state park passes purchased when drivers renew their annual vehicle registration. All that is fair enough, but here’s where it gets weird: From this pot of money, the DNR also spent more than $1,000 last year to buy those giant “trophy” checks that politicians and bureaucrats love to give away in photo-ops staged for the media.

Last year this recreation program gave out 24 grants to communities as diverse as Portage and Flushing Townships, Detroit and Grand Rapids. They didn’t just mail checks at a cost of 44 cents each, however. Instead, DNR bureaucrats drove to the local communities and publicly presented the fake, oversized checks with plenty of back-slapping and mutual congratulations all around. That’s $1,000 spent just on stage-props for PR nonsense associated with just one state grant program, plus all the other expenses incurred including travel and time taken from these bureaucrats’ real jobs.

Given the existence of dozens of state grant programs, it’s possible that much more is spent each year on such promotional self-serving. A Mackinac Center Freedom of Information Act request uncovered that prices for this program’s giant “checks” ranged between $12 to $64, with the annual cost totaling $1,025.95. A small amount was expended on related personnel and travel expenses, but they were also delivered in state vehicles, so a proper accounting of time and materials would render an expense somewhat higher.

This political photo-op, above right, occurred at a monthly Flushing Township board meeting. The person accepting the “check” is township trustee Michael Gardner, who is considered an advocate of limited and frugal government. He told CapCon that during the meeting a DNR official took the podium to describe the driver’s license “Recreation Passport” program and then — with a dramatic pause reminiscent of TV game shows — announced that Flushing Township had won some $18,000 in grant money. Gardner says he was surprised to learn the fake check cost taxpayers $64, not to mention the other expenses incurred by state bureaucrats taking time away from their supposed duties to engage in PR puffery.

“I’m disappointed,” he told CapCon. “Even when officials try to do the right thing by soliciting funds with a voluntary program, they still taint it by wasteful spending.”

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.